Updated August 2026

Directory

Magic Shows in NYC

Currently running shows, listed with the detail that actually helps you choose: where it is, what the room feels like, and who tends to enjoy it. Check the venue for current schedules before you travel.

Magic After Hours at Tannen's Magic Shop
Admit one

Magic After Hours

Tannen's Magic Shop

Noah Levine

An intimate show staged inside the legendary magic shop itself.

Our take: about 20 seats inside a working magic shop is a setting no theater can fake.

John Stessel Live at Moxy Chelsea
Admit one

John Stessel Live

Moxy Chelsea

John Stessel

An exclusive evening of modern close-up magic and mentalism hidden inside Moxy Chelsea, performed inches away in an intimate room.

Our take: the closest you will get to the celebrity table side experience without being famous yourself.

69 Atlantic at Behind the Art of Play shop, Brooklyn Heights
Admit one

69 Atlantic

Behind the Art of Play shop, Brooklyn Heights

Rotating artist in residence

A hidden room behind a shop, with a residency that changes who you see.

Our take: the most serious magic room in the city right now, and the reason to cross the bridge.

Chamber Magic at Lotte New York Palace
Admit one

Chamber Magic

Lotte New York Palace

Steve Cohen

Elegant parlor magic in a hotel salon, performed close enough to see every detail.

Our take: the most polished hour in the city, and the only one where the room itself does half the work.

The Magician at 281 Park Avenue South
Admit one

The Magician

281 Park Avenue South

Dan White

A tightly staged, modern showcase from one of the most in-demand performers in the city.

Our take: the hardest ticket in town and, unusually, worth the scramble.

Speakeasy Magick at The Overlook Bar, Chelsea
Admit one

Speakeasy Magick

The Overlook Bar, Chelsea

Hosted by Todd Robbins

Close-up magic in a speakeasy setting, with performers working table to table.

Our take: the best value per surprise in the city, and the easiest show to bring a skeptic to.

Monday Night Magic at Off-Broadway, Greenwich Village
Admit one

Monday Night Magic

Off-Broadway, Greenwich Village

Rotating lineup

A variety bill with a different set of performers each week.

Our take: the best introduction to the range of the craft, and the one show we would see twice in a month.

Nothing Here Is Real at The Algonquin Hotel
Admit one

Nothing Here Is Real

The Algonquin Hotel

Gary Ferrar

A mentalism-leaning evening in a literary hotel with a long New York history.

Our take: the best price to craft ratio in Midtown, and Ferrar reads a room better than most.

Jamie Allan's Amaze at New World Stages
Admit one

Jamie Allan's Amaze

New World Stages

Jamie Allan

Tech-forward spectacle built around illusion and stagecraft.

Our take: the safest choice with kids in tow, and the least surprising if you go alone.

Urban Illusions at East Village
Admit one

Urban Illusions

East Village

Hayden Childress

A tiny BYOB room where the magic happens a few feet from your chair.

Our take: the most relaxed show in the city, and the informality is the point rather than a shortcut.

Magic In a Bottle at City Winery, The Loft
Admit one

Magic In a Bottle

City Winery, The Loft

David Corsaro

A monthly night of magic in a wine bar loft, casual and social.

Our take: the easiest ticket on this list to say yes to, a low price for a genuinely good night.

The Parlour of Deceptions at The Salmagundi Club, Greenwich Village
Admit one

The Parlour of Deceptions

The Salmagundi Club, Greenwich Village

Daniel Roy

Parlor magic in a historic art club, limited to a small seated audience.

Our take: the closest thing to Chamber Magic downtown, at a fraction of the fuss.

Recently changed

Asi Wind

Asi Wind closed his acclaimed Inner Circle run and is now touring internationally with a new show. There is currently no New York residency to book a seat at.